Home » Tag Archives: Rum Review – He said She Said Taste Test of the Finest Rums of the World

Tag Archives: Rum Review – He said She Said Taste Test of the Finest Rums of the World

“He Said / She Said” Rum Review. We will take an honest approach of the rums that we pick out… Have a favorite that you want us to TEST? Cool! Email us at [email protected]


Top shelf rum or bilge bottle swill. We will blind taste test to let you know whether it is worth the extra money! Some rums are perfect for mixing and some are perfect for sipping. With our rum review rating chart, you will get an idea of what we think. We’ve been surprised by our results – we think you will be too!


About Clint and Terry: We have sampled many a dram over our 33 years of marriage and quite often we don’t fully agree. Could be the difference is male/female taste buds. Or, somebody is just wrong.

Rum Review: Dictador 12 Years — Colombia

The minute Terry realized Dictador rum was made in Cartagena, Colombia she knew we had to review. Cartagena is a magical city of narrow streets with flower-draped window boxes and colorful street performers that charm and entertain. Colombia is one …

Read More »

Rum Review: Papa’s Pilar 24

Papa's Pilar

Our favorite tour in Key West, by far, was the Hemingway Home on Whitehead Street.  Ernest Hemingway, known by many as “Papa,” had a penchant for adventure and fine rums. The Hemingway Rum Company pays homage to this icon of …

Read More »

Mount Gay Black Barrel

For over 30 years Mount Gay has sponsored sailing regattas around the world. Sailors proudly wear their Mount Gay Red Caps as symbols of participating in one of 150 hosted regattas each year. As the day of racing ends, the …

Read More »

Rum Review: Villa Rica – Olé Mexico

  Since we began our rum tasting adventure we have reviewed over 30 rums from around the United States and the Caribbean Islands. Not once have we ventured into Mexico. Maybe it’s because Mexico is better known for its tequilas. …

Read More »

Review: 12-Year Old El Dorado Rum from Guyana

El Dorado Rum

                The beautiful red box with a square-rigger on the front drew our attention. El Dorado Rum is a 12-year old rum from Guyana on South America’s coast. Not having much information about the …

Read More »

Is Ron Zacapa Truly the Benchmark?

We were introduced to sipping rums by Clint’s best friend Jim Brazil many years ago. Back then, one rum tasted like the other.  Vanilla, molasses and some with spices we couldn’t quite identify. Then Jim pulled out the pinnacle of …

Read More »

Kaniché XO – Barbados

One day we got a strange text message. “We’re having a rum tasting this week. What would you recommend?” We couldn’t type fast enough. After giving him a list of our favorites he texts back, “Have you ever had Kaniché?” Honestly, …

Read More »

Pusser’s Rum Aged 15 Years

Pussers Rum

On a recent trip to Annapolis, we had to make a stop at Mill’s Fine Wine and Spirits to check out the rum selection stocked for incoming cruisers. Lo and behold there was the Pusser’s Rum Aged 15 Years; a …

Read More »

Doorly’s 12 Year Old – Barbados


Barbados is one of our favorite Caribbean Islands. There you will find the most genuine people and, in our opinion, some of the best rums in the world. When we were there we bought a Doorly’s XO and have nursed …

Read More »

Angostura 1919 8-year Old

Angostura 1919 8 year old rum review

We were standing in the middle of the rum aisle trying to decide on a rum to review. Sipping or mixing? Caribbean or South American? We are fortunate to live in Florida which offers us a wide variety of rums. …

Read More »

Don Pancho Origenes Reserva 8 Year Old

Don Pancho Origenes Reserva 8

We first sampled Don Pancho Origenes Reserva 8 year old rum in March writing a very lackluster review. Taking a step back, we revisited the rum in May, opting to sample as the producers of the rum suggested: “neat, on …

Read More »

Ron Abuelo 12 Year Old

Rum: Ron Abuelo 12 year old

  Have you ever gone to a movie based on your favorite books and left the theater wishing you had never gone. Would your opinion of the movie have been different if you hadn’t read the book? When doing our …

Read More »

At Odds with Dos Maderas PX 5+5

Rum Review: Dos Maderas PX 5+5

Our son and daughter-in-law surprised us with a rum of the month subscription from Taster’s Club, a subscription based company featuring whiskey, tequila and rum. Taster’s Club carefully selects “must have” rums from around the world and surprises its members …

Read More »

Atlantico Private Cask

RUM: Atlantico Private Cask

What do you give rum reviewers for Christmas? Rum, of course. We are very fortunate our friends also have refined palates for sipping rums. When we opened Atlantico Private Cask we immediately wanted to share with those gathered, however, after …

Read More »

Captain Morgan White Rum

Captain Morgan White Rum Taste Test

After our review “Top Shelf vs. Bottom Shelf” hit the stands, reader John Sans wrote, “Please try the control test without using Bacardi. Though Bacardi may be the best selling rum in the world, that doesn’t qualify it to be …

Read More »

Plantation Barbados 2000 Rum

Plantation Barbados 2000 Rum

On the first cool, rainy day of the season I went looking for a sipping rum which would remind me of the islands and warm my soul. High on the shelf was the Plantation Collection, vintage rums blended by Maison …

Read More »

Top Shelf vs. Bottom Shelf Rum

  When it comes to purchasing a mixing rum we typically go bottom shelf, reserving our cash for the finer sipping rums. That philosophy recently got us thinking. Is a more expensive, top shelf rum worth the extra money and …

Read More »