Discovering Stock Island: A Hidden Gem in the Florida Keys
Explore the evolving charm of Stock Island, Florida, where history meets modernity. Learn about its rich maritime past, vibrant present, and how it’s becoming a top destination for water sports, luxury accommodations, and unique local cuisine.
Stock Island: A Boater’s Paradise
Stock Island, located just a mile or so from Key West, is a lesser-known but rapidly evolving destination in the Florida Keys. This island has long been a hub for those who love the water, and it’s now becoming a hotspot for visitors seeking a mix of adventure, history, and relaxation.
Meet Capt. Justin Pasca: Your Guide to Low Latitude Adventures
Capt. Justin Pasca lives aboard a sailboat off the coast of Key West and operates a six-pack “downeaster” boat based in Stock Island. Pasca, originally from New Jersey, moved to Stock Island five years ago, coinciding with the redevelopment of the local marina. Under his charter company, Low Latitude Adventures, Pasca offers customizable trips, including fishing, snorkeling, diving, or simply enjoying a sunset cruise. His boat, designed for comfort and stability, can accommodate up to six passengers, making it ideal for exploring the Atlantic Ocean and the world’s third-largest barrier reef.
The Maritime Heritage of Stock Island
Stock Island has a rich maritime history, deeply connected to the fishing and shrimping industries that once thrived here. While the number of shrimp boats has dwindled, the island’s waterfront remains a significant asset, with potential that residents and developers are keen to realize.
Hogfish Bar and Grill: A Local Culinary Icon
One of Stock Island’s culinary treasures is the Hogfish Bar and Grill, opened by Bobby and Michelle Mongelli in 2002. Originally serving just one sandwich, the restaurant has gained fame for its fried hogfish sandwich, featured on the Today Show. The dish, served on Cuban bread with mushroom, onion, and Swiss cheese, has become a local favorite. Bobby Mongelli, who spearfishes for hogfish to meet demand, chose Stock Island for his business because of its “old” Key West vibe, reminiscent of the island’s bustling shrimping days.
The Evolution of Stock Island: From Shrimp Boats to Upscale Resorts
As Stock Island continues to develop, upscale hotels and artists have moved in, bringing a new energy to the area. The Perry Hotel, with its 100 rooms, offers a blend of luxury and rustic charm. The hotel’s décor features concrete, metal, and reclaimed wood, with rooms that boast expansive balconies and local artwork. Meanwhile, the Oceanside Marina, a full-service resort that opened in January 2017, adds to the island’s appeal with 175 hotel rooms and various charter services.
Luxury Meets Rustic Charm: The Perry Hotel and Oceanside Marina
The Perry Hotel stands out with its unique design, including driftwood-inspired flooring and outdoor showers in select rooms. The hotel is also dog-friendly and showcases local artwork, further connecting visitors to the island’s culture. Both The Perry and Oceanside Marina offer easy access to the water, with charters departing right from their docks, making them perfect for those looking to indulge in water sports like paddling, fishing, and diving.
Stock Island’s Community Events: I Love Stock Island Festival
To promote its unique culture and attract visitors, Stock Island hosts events like the “I Love Stock Island Festival” in early December. This weekend event, started in 2016, includes activities such as trolley tours, rum tastings, food truck offerings, and an evening boat parade. One highlight is the Christmas tree made from lobster traps and buoys, reflecting the island’s maritime heritage.
A Glimpse into Stock Island’s Rich History
Stock Island is steeped in history, with its name dating back to at least 1850. Over the years, it has been home to cattle, auto racing, and even the largest drive-in theater screen in Florida in the 1950s. The island’s colorful past adds to its charm, making it a fascinating destination for history buffs.
Conclusion: Why Stock Island is a Must-Visit in the Florida Keys
Stock Island is quickly becoming a must-visit destination in the Florida Keys, blending its rich history with modern amenities. Whether you’re looking to explore its maritime heritage, enjoy local cuisine, or relax at a luxury resort, Stock Island offers something for everyone. With its unique charm and evolving attractions, it’s the perfect place to experience the authentic Florida Keys.
Jill Borski has written for ALL AT SEA since 2016.
Worth your time?
Thanks — noted.
