Top 10 Reasons to Visit Colombia’s Hidden Caribbean Islands

San Andrés and Providencia offer history, snorkeling, scooter adventures, and some of the Caribbean’s quirkiest bus stops—all off the radar of most cruisers.

When most people think of Colombia, they picture the mainland and have no idea that two Colombian islands sit in the middle of the Caribbean Sea, much closer to Nicaragua than the mainland. These hidden gems, San Andrés and Providencia, are incredible destinations for boaters. Captain Shane and Lily recently explored both islands and shared their favorite reasons why cruisers should add them to their charts.

10. Sailing in Henry Morgan’s Wake

Providencia and San Andrés were once the strongholds of the infamous pirate Henry Morgan. As we sailed in from the north, the volcanic island of Providencia rose dramatically from the sea, and Lily lit up with excitement. I was taken by the history—we were literally following the same paths as pirates and privateers. Morgan’s Head (a rock formation) and Morgan’s Crack (a cleft between two hills) still mark his presence.

9. Providencia’s Sheltered Anchorage

While San Andrés’ anchorage on the east coast can be bumpy, Providencia’s anchorage is a dream. Tucked between the main island and the smaller Santa Catalina Island, it offers great protection, beautiful sunrises, and easy access to shore. It’s the perfect jumping-off point to explore Providencia.

8. Snorkeling the Eastern Reefs

Providencia’s east coast is protected by vibrant coral reefs, creating excellent snorkeling opportunities. While you wouldn’t bring your big boat near the reefs, they are easily reached by dinghy or local tour boats. The water is clear, the fish abundant, and the coral formations stunning.

7. Driftwood Sculpture Garden (San Andrés)

While touring San Andrés by scooter, we stumbled upon a driftwood sculpture garden on the island’s southern end. It was humble, but the artistry was amazing. Our favorite was a striking shark sculpture that felt perfectly at home near the sea.

6. Manzanillo Beach and Rope Swings

We’re not usually beach people, but Manzanillo Beach at the southern tip of Providencia won us over. With a reggae bar and palm trees swaying over turquoise water, it was the ideal island hangout. We found a long rope swing tied to a tree and laughed like kids.

5. Santa Catalina Island & Fort Ruins

Accessible only by footbridge, the tiny island of Santa Catalina has no cars and a relaxed charm. We wandered past small shops and homes to the ruins of an old fort with two cannons guarding the anchorage. It’s a peaceful walk with a lot of character.

4. First Baptist Church Viewpoint (San Andrés)

This beautiful church sits on a hill and offers a rare chance to climb into its steeple. From the top, we had panoramic views of San Andrés and its surrounding reefs. It was a highlight of our island tour and gave us a great perspective of the area.

3. Scooters & Island Roads

Renting scooters on both islands gave us freedom to explore. Providencia was our favorite—quiet, chill, and low-key. San Andrés, while more touristy, still had scenic ring roads and fun stops. Scooters made it easy to discover off-the-beaten-path spots.

2. Rose Island Sandbar Party

Just off San Andrés’ east coast is Rose Island, a dreamy sandbar that appears or vanishes with the tide. Lined with pop-up restaurants and music, it’s where everyone goes to relax and socialize. You must take a water taxi, but it’s totally worth it.

1. Artistic Bus Stops (Providencia)

While scootering around Providencia, I noticed that every bus stop was unique—giant, whimsical sculptures scattered across the island. I was so taken by them, we looped around a second time just to photograph each one. It felt like an island-wide art gallery.

Providencia and San Andrés may not be on every cruiser’s itinerary, but they should be. If you’re heading through the Western Caribbean toward Panama or Colombia, don’t miss these islands. Between the culture, snorkeling, and unforgettable roadside surprises, they’re well worth the stop.

Captain Shane and Lily spent a week between the two islands and then set sail for Panama.

Shane McClellan has written for ALL AT SEA since 2016.